You can usually tell when something feels wrong with someone. It’s much harder to say what would feel right.
Plenty of people date for years on a vague hunch. They know they want “someone kind” and “a real connection”, and then they spend months with people who are neither, because the hunch never got specific enough to rule anyone out. Others carry a long checklist of height, job and star sign and still end up confused about why the people who tick every box leave them cold.
Neither approach tells you much about what you actually need. That takes some deliberate work: looking at your values, your past, the people you already love, and the way you behave when you like someone. None of it is complicated, but it does ask you to be honest.
The 12 steps below draw on research into dating, compatibility and singlehood, most of it from the last two years. Each one ends with something small you can do this week.
1. Decide what kind of relationship you’re looking for right now
Before you think about the person, think about the shape of the thing. Are you after something committed and long-term? Something light while you finish a degree or settle into a new city? Or are you, honestly, not that interested in a relationship at all at the moment?
All three answers are common. The Kinsey Institute’s 15th annual Singles in America study, released in September 2026, surveyed close to 5,000 US single adults between March and April 2026. The study is funded by the dating company Match, so treat it as a large commercial-backed survey rather than an independent poll. Its codebook shows how spread out people’s intentions are:
| What US singles said (Singles in America, 2026) | Share |
|---|---|
| Actively looking for a committed relationship | 16.3% |
| Not actively looking, but open to one | 44.7% |
| Would prefer to stay unattached | 24.1% |
The biggest group sits in the middle. They’re open to a relationship but not chasing one. That’s a perfectly reasonable place to be. It becomes a problem only when you haven’t noticed you’re there, and you go on dates with people who are very clearly looking for a partner tomorrow.
Picture this: you match with someone who mentions on the second date that they’d like to be engaged within two years. If you’re in “open but not looking” mode, that one sentence should change how you respond. If you haven’t named your own mode, it just feels like vague pressure you can’t explain.
Your current answer isn’t permanent either. People’s intentions change after a breakup, a move, or when they’re starting over in life at 30. What matters is knowing which one is true this season.
Start small: write one sentence that begins “Right now, I want a relationship that is…” and finish it in under 15 words.
2. Name the values you won’t trade away
Values sound abstract until they show up on a Tuesday night. Then they turn into very concrete questions. Do you save or spend? Does Sunday belong to your family or to the two of you? Do you say the hard thing, or keep the peace?
The mechanism goes roughly like this. Your values decide your everyday choices, and those choices keep coming back. A gap in values doesn’t cause one big fight. It causes the same small fight, over and over, because the trigger keeps returning. That’s a logical chain rather than a tested finding, but most people who’ve had the same argument for the fifth time will recognise it.
There’s an interesting twist in the research, though. A 2025 scoping review in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, led by Annika From at the University of Michigan, pulled together 339 articles on similarity in romantic couples. Studies that measured actual similarity in beliefs and values mostly found no strong link with relationship quality or stability. Perceived similarity, meaning feeling that your partner shares your outlook, was linked to satisfaction far more consistently. The review mainly covered married, heterosexual, US couples, and it couldn’t rule out that happy couples simply see themselves as more alike.
So you don’t need a values clone. You need someone with whom your core values feel understood and respected. To judge that, you first have to know what those values are.
Pick your top five from a list that might include honesty, family, adventure, security, faith, ambition, independence and kindness. Then cut it to three. The three that survive are the ones worth discussing early. You’ll also handle conflicts about them better if you’ve already practised how to argue without fighting.
3. Write your dealbreakers before your wish list
Most of us find it easier to list what we want than what we refuse. The refusals may matter more.
In a set of six studies with more than 6,500 participants, published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin in 2015, Peter Jonason, Justin Garcia, Gregory Webster, Norman Li and Helen Fisher looked at “dealbreakers”, the traits that make people lose interest in a potential partner. People gave dealbreakers more weight than they gave positive traits. The effect was stronger for long-term relationships than for short-term ones. In a nationally representative sample of 2,744 single Americans, participants picked an average of about six dealbreakers each. Common ones included anger issues, being abusive, being untrustworthy and having different relationship goals.
The study is from 2015, which is old by this article’s standards. It stays here because it’s the foundational work on the topic, and a 2022 follow-up led by Jonason again found that learning about a dealbreaker lowered people’s interest, more so in a long-term context.
Your dealbreakers will differ from anyone else’s, and that’s the point. Keep them few and serious. “Must love hiking” is a preference. “Must not lie to me about money” is a dealbreaker. Once you’ve written them down, deciding is the easy part. The hard part is sticking to it when someone charming breaks one, which is where knowing how to stick to your decision helps.
Give it a go: write five dealbreakers, then remove any that are really just preferences in disguise.
4. Look for the pattern, not the “type”
“I always go for the same type” usually means hair colour, job or a certain kind of confidence. Often, though, the thing that repeats is a dynamic rather than a person.
Sociologist Alicia M. Walker, PhD, who studies intimate relationships, argued in a June 2026 Psychology Today piece that having a “type” may say more about recurring emotional patterns than about looks, careers or personality. She points to attachment research suggesting that early relationships shape what we expect from closeness, trust and conflict. Those expectations then work as templates later on. Her bottom line is short: “Attraction patterns are not destiny.”
The mechanism is familiarity. Something you’ve lived through many times feels predictable, and predictable can feel safe even when it hurts. That’s how the slightly cold, hard-to-read person ends up feeling like chemistry, while someone steady and warm feels oddly flat. The flat feeling may simply be the absence of anxiety.
Learning about attachment styles can help you put names to what you notice. You don’t need a diagnosis, though. You need a list.
A quick experiment: for your last three relationships or situationships, write down how each one felt at month three and how it ended. Circle any word that appears more than once.
5. Hold your ideal-partner checklist loosely
Lists are useful. They’re also less predictive than most of us assume.
A huge registered report in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology tested this in 2025. Paul Eastwick and dozens of colleagues, working with the Psychological Science Accelerator, collected data from 10,358 people in 43 countries and 22 languages. Participants rated how much they wanted 35 traits in a partner, then rated real people in their lives on those same traits. In the worldwide preference-matching study, people did evaluate partners who matched their overall pattern of ideals more positively, with an effect the authors call small to medium. For individual traits, though, the effects were very small. People also misjudged themselves. Both men and women underestimated how much attractiveness actually mattered to them, and women overestimated how much earning potential did.
In plain terms, your overall picture carries some signal. The specific line items carry very little.
The Singles in America 2026 data points the same way. About 34% of singles said they keep a mental checklist for a long-term partner, and almost 46% said they’ve fallen for someone who didn’t match most of theirs.
So keep the list, but treat it as a rough draft. Hold on to the items that describe how you want to be treated, and loosen up on the ones that describe a CV or a profile photo.
Your move: go through your checklist and mark each item “how they treat me” or “what they look like on paper”. Keep the first group firm and let the second one bend.
6. Borrow from the friendships that already work
Your friendships are a ready-made dataset. You’ve already tested which kinds of people make you feel safe, funny, understood and energised.
Romance also grows out of friendship far more often than films suggest. A 2021 study in Social Psychological and Personality Science, led by Danu Anthony Stinson at the University of Victoria, analysed data from nearly 1,900 university students and crowdsourced adults. About two-thirds (66%, according to the university’s release) said their current or most recent romance began as a friendship. Among people in their twenties and in LGBTQ+ communities, the figure reached 85%. Nearly half of the university students said friends-first was their preferred route. Stinson summed it up neatly: “the lines between friendship and romance are blurry.” The study is now five years old. It’s still the most detailed estimate available, but newer figures may differ.
The practical upshot is simple. The qualities that make your best friendships work, like reliability, humour, honesty and being easy to be quiet with, are a sensible starting point for what you want in a partner. That’s because they’re the qualities that hold up once the novelty fades. If you’re not sure where to start, look at whose company leaves you calmer rather than more drained. The skills behind good friendships (solid social skills, mostly) carry over too.
Think of the two friends you’d call first with good news, and write down three things they do that make you feel like yourself.
7. Learn what “healthy” looks like so you can spot it
If your earlier relationships were chaotic, you may not have a clear picture of what a good one looks like day to day. That’s worth fixing before you choose again, not after.
Love is respect, a project of the US National Domestic Violence Hotline, says healthy relationships rest on four elements: healthy communication, healthy boundaries, mutual respect, and support for one another. Its guidance (page last updated March 2025) also stresses checking in on each other’s needs while still giving each other space and privacy. The organisation also states plainly that abuse is always a choice.
These four elements are useful because you can see them. You can’t easily check “chemistry” or “soulmate energy” from the outside. You can check whether someone respects a “no”, whether they’re curious about your day, and whether they try to cut you off from friends. If you’ve been with someone controlling before, it’s worth reading up on dealing with a narcissistic person in a relationship so the early signs look less normal.
Say you’ve been seeing someone for a month. They’re thoughtful about plans and good company, but they sulk for a day whenever you see friends without them. Measured against those four elements, that sulking is a boundary problem. It’s not a charming quirk.
Test it this week: take the four elements and rate your last relationship from 1 to 5 on each. The lowest score shows you which one to protect hardest next time.
8. Put your answer on paper
Knowing what you want seems to change how dating actually feels.
McGill University researchers Katya Kredl, Dita Kubin and John Lydon published two studies in Personal Relationships in 2025, each with more than 180 single young adults who were actively dating. They measured “relationship clarity”, meaning how clearly someone understands what they’re looking for. As McGill’s summary of the relationship clarity study explains, singles who dated without that clarity reported more loneliness and lower life satisfaction. The second study followed people for two months and gave the team more confidence that low clarity leads to loneliness rather than the reverse. That’s still self-reported data over a short period, not proof of cause.
Kredl offered one likely reason: “People low in relationship clarity may be less selective in dating contexts.” Being less selective means more dates with incompatible people. Uncertainty may also make people read neutral signals as rejection.
Writing things down is the cheapest way to build clarity. It turns a fog of feelings into sentences you can check, argue with and update. It’s also good practice for the self-awareness behind emotional intelligence, which you’ll need when real people test your list.
Here’s a simple way in: on one page, write your answer from step 1, your three values from step 2, your dealbreakers from step 3 and the friendship qualities from step 6. Date it, and reread it after your next three dates.
9. Make peace with being single first
It’s hard to judge what you want when part of you just wants the loneliness to stop.
The chain is easy to follow. If being single feels frightening, almost any partner looks better than none. You then lower your bar without noticing, and you stay longer in relationships that aren’t working. Research by Stephanie Spielmann and colleagues, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2013, found exactly that. A stronger fear of being single predicted settling for less: staying in unsatisfying relationships, and showing romantic interest in less responsive dating partners. In a speed-dating study, it also predicted being less selective. That paper is older, but it’s still the reference point for the “settling” effect.
Newer data makes singlehood look much less scary than that fear suggests. A 2026 study in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin by Elaine Hoan, Geoff MacDonald and Matthew Johnson followed 2,930 never-married, unpartnered adults in Germany for 11 years. Around 90% of each age group stayed above the midpoint for life satisfaction across all 11 years. The data comes from one country and only covers people up to their late forties, but the pattern is reassuring.
Being okay alone doesn’t mean you have to stay alone. It means you choose a partner rather than grab one. If solitude still feels hard, try learning to enjoy being alone as a skill in its own right.
Start small: plan one solo evening this week doing something you’d normally save for a date, and notice how it actually feels.
10. Date like a curious scientist, not a judge
You can’t work out everything from your sofa. At some point you have to meet people, pay attention and collect real data about yourself.
Logan Ury, a behavioural scientist and Director of Relationship Science at the dating app Hinge, has made this her main message. Speaking on The Knowledge Project podcast in March 2025, she urged daters to stop chasing an instant spark. She suggests favouring “slow burn” connections, where your liking grows as you learn more about someone’s character. In other interviews she has made the same point from the opposite side. A missing spark doesn’t predict failure, and a strong one doesn’t guarantee anything.
There’s a useful comparison here. A first date is a bit like a film trailer. It shows you tone and a few highlights, and it’s built to make you feel something quickly. It holds up because trailers really do reveal some things, such as genre and pace. It breaks down because a person, unlike a film, changes as they relax with you, so treat the comparison as a reminder to stay curious rather than as evidence.
Curiosity is a habit you can practise (staying curious as an adult applies here too). So is asking questions that go beyond “So, what do you do?”, which is where knowing how to have a good conversation pays off.
Next time, do this: after each date, ask yourself two questions. “Did I feel more like myself or less?” and “Do I want to know more about them?” Two yeses are worth a second date, spark or no spark.
11. Picture the relationship two years in, not two weeks
Early dating flatters everyone. The real test is what happens once life gets ordinary.
Long-term data shows how gradual change can be. Janina Bühler of Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz and Ulrich Orth of the University of Bern published a study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in March 2025. They analysed data from 11,295 people in national panel studies from Germany, the UK, Australia and the Netherlands who had gone through a separation. Satisfaction typically fell slowly for years, then dropped sharply in a “terminal phase” lasting roughly 7 to 28 months before the breakup. Bühler, who also works as a couples therapist, said that acting before that steep drop is likely to be more effective than acting once it’s underway. The findings describe average trends, not what will happen to any one couple.
For someone still working out what they want, the lesson is to judge a relationship by how it handles drift, not by how it feels in month one. Ask whether the two of you can name a problem early and fix it. A problem nobody raises in month four is still there in year two, only bigger.
Picture this: you’re six months in, and the texts that used to arrive all day now come mainly in the evenings. One version of this relationship talks about it calmly and adjusts. Another version turns quiet and resentful. Which one you’d want says a lot about your needs. If you’re already further along and unsure, it’s worth reading about how to know it’s time to end a relationship.
A quick experiment: imagine an average Wednesday with this person two years from now. Write down what the evening looks like, who’s doing the dishes, and how you’d raise something that bothered you.
12. Say what you want out loud, early
Clarity you keep to yourself only does half its job. The other person has to know too.
Young daters say they want this. Tinder’s Year in Swipe 2025 survey, run by the polling firm Opinium among 4,000 actively dating 18- to 25-year-olds in the US, UK, Canada and Australia between October and November 2025, found that 60% want clearer communication about intentions. 56% said honest conversations matter most, and 64% said emotional honesty is what dating needs most. It’s a commercial poll from a dating app, so take the exact figures with some caution. The direction is still hard to miss.
Most people want the other person to be upfront. Far fewer go first. That’s the gap you can close. You don’t need a big “where is this going” talk on date two. A light, early statement of intent (“I’m dating with something longer-term in mind, no pressure, just wanted to be clear”) saves weeks of guessing on both sides.
It takes a little nerve. Being more courageous in small, low-stakes moments like this makes the bigger conversations easier later.
Your move: by the third date, say your answer from step 1 in one plain sentence, then ask them the same question and listen properly to the reply.
What to do when you slip
You will slip. You’ll date someone who broke a dealbreaker because they were fun. You’ll ignore your own list for three months. You’ll end up in a relationship that feels very much like the last one.
That’s not proof you don’t know what you want. It’s information. How you treat yourself afterwards matters more than the slip itself.
A 2024 study in Revista de Psicología by Gonzalo Peña-Muñante and Carmen Pozo-Muñoz of the University of Almería surveyed 506 students after a romantic breakup. Self-compassion helped explain the link between breakup distress and flourishing. Students who were kinder to themselves after a breakup tended to flourish more. The study was correlational, so it shows a link rather than cause and effect. Still, it fits a wider pattern: harsh self-criticism after a setback tends to keep people stuck rather than help them learn.
So treat a slip like an experiment that produced unexpected data. Ask what you missed, when you first noticed it, and why you overrode it. Then update your one-page list from step 8. If the inner voice turns nasty, it’s worth working on how to stop hating yourself as seriously as you’d work on your dating choices. One rough relationship, or several, doesn’t erase what you’ve learned about yourself.
Conclusion
Working out what you want in a relationship isn’t something you do once. It’s a short list you keep testing against real life: what kind of relationship you’re after, what you value, what you refuse, how you want to be treated, and how you want to feel on an ordinary Wednesday.
Start with the one-page list from step 8 tonight. Say it out loud to someone soon, whether that’s a date or a friend. Then let the next few months add to it.
For more on dating, communication and the people closest to you, browse our relationships articles.












